Wednesday, May 10, 2023

Part 1: Study examines language in Ukraine war coverage
I recently conducted a small study that examines language usage in coverage of the Ukraine-Russia war. The details and results are below. It’s not surprising that traditional/war language outnumbered peace/peace journalism language 5 to 1. --Ed

This study examines language used in reporting about the Russia-Ukraine war, and discusses whether the language used in this reporting reflects traditional/war framing or peace journalism framing.

Research question R1: Regarding Russia-Ukraine war news coverage, does the language used reflect a traditional/war orientation, or a peace journalism orientation?

Research question R2: Within stories discussing a possible settlement to the war, is language used that would indicate a framing that dismisses, marginalizes, and criticizes a potential settlement?

Both questions are researched the Nexis Uni (formerly Lexis-Nexis) database. It analyzes the prevalence of violent, emotive, inflammatory language, and peace language, in news content, specifically newspapers, magazines/journalists, newswires/press releases, and broadcast transcripts for the month of March, 2023. For example, a search was done for “Russia Ukraine War,” then a second search done within the “Russia Ukraine War”  results for a word or term like “battle.”

The content analysis used was based on a revised version of a widely published chart comparing peace journalism and war (traditional) journalism approaches. A version of this chart was first published by Jake Lynch and Annabel McGoldrick in Peace Journalism in 2005, and can be seen in the Lynch/Freear Afghanistan study paper (2023), Table 1.

The traditional/war journalism terms searched for (R1) all highlight (and in some cases sensationalize) violence, and are emotive and inflammatory. The peace journalism terms all highlight peace and peace initiatives.

Findings: R1-War vs Peace Language
The study’s findings are contained in the chart below.

Chart 1: Traditional vs. Peace Journalism terms

Traditional/war journalism language

Number

Peace/peace journalism language

Number

Battle

4428

Negotiations

647

Weapons

6927

Peace Talks

889

Attack.

8111

Cease Fire

329

Offensive

2695

Peace

6275

War Crimes

4193

Treaty

1566

Tank

3989

Mediation

763

Prisoner

9393

Reconciliation

336

Killing

19312

Justice

3074

Refugee

6868

Reparations

116

Missile

8443

Compromise

926

TOTAL

74,359

TOTAL

14,923

NOTES:
a. Total number of articles on Nexis Uni in March, 2023 for “Russia Ukraine War”—355,979. 309,724 articles were from newspapers, 30,451 from broadcast transcripts, and 15,804 from magazines and journals.
b. Total number of hits for the 20 traditional/war terms and the peace/peace journalism terms  combined-89,282

NOTE: DETAILS AND FINDINGS ABOUT RESEARCH QUESTION 2, AND A DISCUSSION OF THESE FINDINGS, WILL BE GIVEN IN MY NEXT BLOG POST. STAY TUNED.

 


No comments:

Post a Comment